The Majority’s Reasoning

The Case

The case is Scanlan v. Coalition for Open Democracy, decided by the Supreme Court of the United States on October 22, 2026. The parties are David M. Scanlan, Secretary of State of New Hampshire, et al., and Coalition for Open Democracy. The Court granted an application for stay.

The Question

The question in the case is whether the District Court for the District of New Hampshire properly issued a preliminary injunction to correct a publicized misstatement about what New Hampshire’s election rules required, in light of the Purcell principle, which cautions against federal courts altering election rules on the eve of an election.

The Reasoning

The Court held that the District Court did not clearly err in determining that correcting the misstatement was necessary to ensure that certain citizens were not unduly burdened in their exercise of the fundamental right to vote. The Court emphasized that the District Court’s injunction was reasonably designed to address alleged misinformation, not to change the law. The Court also noted that the injunction promoted the interests protected by the Purcell principle, as it prevented voter confusion and misinformation about the State’s election rules.

The Holding

The holding is that the application for stay presented to Justice Jackson and by her referred to the Court is granted. The October 2, 2026, and October 5, 2026, orders granting preliminary injunctive relief by the District Court are stayed pending the disposition of the appeal in the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit and disposition of a petition for a writ of certiorari, if such a writ is timely sought. Should certiorari be denied, the stay shall terminate automatically. In the event certiorari is granted, the stay shall terminate upon the sending down of the judgment of the Court.

Practical Significance

The practical significance of this holding is that federal courts may issue preliminary injunctions to correct publicized misstatements about a State’s election rules, even close to an election, as long as the injunction is reasonably designed to address the alleged misinformation and does not change the law. This decision provides guidance on the application of the Purcell principle in cases involving alleged misinformation about election rules.

The Majority’s Reasoning

The majority held that the District Court did not clearly err in determining that correcting the misstatement was necessary to ensure that certain citizens were not unduly burdened in their exercise of the fundamental right to vote. The majority emphasized that the District Court’s injunction was reasonably designed to address alleged misinformation, not to change the law. The majority also noted that the injunction promoted the interests protected by the Purcell principle, as it prevented voter confusion and misinformation about the State’s election rules.

The Dissent

Justice Jackson dissented, arguing that the Purcell principle arose in a particular context and that this Court has yet to fully define its limits. Justice Jackson stated that a case involving a court order like the one at issue here, which left the state election rule untouched, does not necessarily fall within the ambit of Purcell and its concern about federal courts “changing the election rules” at the last minute. Justice Jackson further argued that the District Court’s injunction was reasonably designed to address alleged misinformation and prevent voter confusion, which promoted the interests protected by the Purcell principle.

The Practical Significance

The practical significance of this holding is that federal courts may issue preliminary injunctions to correct publicized misstatements about a State’s election rules, even close to an election, as long as the injunction is reasonably designed to address the alleged misinformation and does not change the law. This decision provides guidance on the application of the Purcell principle in cases involving alleged misinformation about election rules.

Research Note

This piece is general research material, not legal advice.

Source

Opinion: Scanlan v. Coalition for Open Democracy Revisions: 10/23/26, Supreme Court of the United States (2026-10-22). Retrieved via CourtListener.